Skip to main content

Troy Weaver is turning Trey Murphy III into Bojan Bogdanovic

This situation seems familiar...
ByAaron Kellerstrass
Dec 27, 2025; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA;  New Orleans Pelicans forward Trey Murphy III (25) reacts to making a three-point basket against the Phoenix Suns during the first half at Smoothie King Center. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Lew-Imagn Images
Dec 27, 2025; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA; New Orleans Pelicans forward Trey Murphy III (25) reacts to making a three-point basket against the Phoenix Suns during the first half at Smoothie King Center. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Lew-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Last summer, Trey Murphy III was one of the ubiquitous names in trade rumors and was briefly connected to the Detroit Pistons before New Orleans made it clear that they weren’t going to trade him. 

Before doing so, they set a laughable price for Murphy III that no one in the league wanted to touch, as Dumars and Weaver were looking for 4+ first-round picks to go along with a talented young player. 

With the ink on the new lottery rules not yet dry, teams were reluctant to give up that kind of draft package for a guy who has never made an All-Star team, and at best is a second or third option. 

We’ve seen trades like this work out recently (Mikal Bridges for the Knicks) and also seen them flop (Desmond Bane for the Magic), but no team was willing to take that risk for TMIII. 

The decision not to move him over the summer may come back to haunt Troy Weaver, and the whole situation has some similarities with one that played out for the Pistons. 

Troy Weaver is waiting too long to make a trade, just like he did with the Pistons 

The Pelicans stunk last season but decided to run it back without any significant additions. Most pundits felt they probably should have cashed in some of their chips, recouped assets and started over, but instead Dumars and Weaver doubled down on what didn’t work. 

Instead of trading TMIII when his value was at its peak last summer, he held onto him hoping that by some miracle the team would be good, which all metrics defied, or that TMIII would be even better and drive up the price at the deadline. 

Instead, his team is predictably a dumpster fire that just got blown out by the Pistons’ deep reserves on the second game of a back-to-back on their home floor.   

The hope that Murphy would raise his value has also tanked, as he just missed his 6th-straight game with a nebulous knee injury and wasn’t playing well before he got hurt. He’s averaged 15 points per game this season, and his numbers are down across the board. 

If this all sounds familiar, it’s because it is similar to how the Bojan Bogdanovic situation played out in Detroit. Bojan put up big numbers on a bad Pistons team (just like TMIII last season with the Pels), averaging over 20 ppg, and it looked like a no-brainer the terrible rebuilding Pistons would trade him for assets. 

Troy Weaver (then GM of the Pistons) kept making unrealistic demands, and at one point, it looked certain that the Pistons would get at least a first-round pick out of someone for the veteran Bogdanovic. 

Instead, Weaver held onto him for another season, Bogdanovic kept getting hurt, and the Pistons ended up getting jack squat for him other than two second-round picks and six games of Quentin Grimes. 

I’m not saying the same will happen to TMIII, as he’s a younger player who likely still has his best years in front of him, and Bogdanovic was at the end of his career, but you can already see his value declining. 

Yesterday, there was speculation (who knows if any of it is true) that the Pelicans had “lowered” their demands to JUST three first-round picks, and the response was telling, as there are few around who think TMIII is worth that cost when he’s not even scoring more points per game than Saddiq Bey.  Duncan Robinson and Daniss Jenkins have both been better than Murphy III this season and no one would suggest they are worth anywhere approaching three first-round picks.

I feel bad for the Pels fans, who are going through the same thing we Pistons fans went through with Weaver, watching him squander assets and double down on roster that don’t make sense. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google