Trade rumor season has come early this year after early speculation that Trey Murphy III might finally be made available at the trade deadline. He’s a player the Detroit Pistons have shown reported interest in, so naturally their name has already come up.
I wrote about TMIII yesterday, mostly in context of Troy Weaver tanking his value, much like he did with Bojan Bogdanovic, as it has been speculated that the asking price for TMIII is going down.
But even that “lowered” price is a steep one, especially for a guy who is currently injured and has not had a good start to his season, though we do have to consider the context of his team, which is a mess.
Sam Amico of Hoops Wire came up with four fake trades for TMIII, one of which was to the Pistons:
Pelicans get: Duncan Robinson, Isaiah Joe, 3 first-round picks
Pistons get: Trey Murphy III
In this trade proposal, the Pistons are giving up their two best 3-point shooters and THREE first-round picks for Trey Murphy III, all of which are unprotected.
It’s difficult to imagine Trajan Langdon breaking precedent with a risky trade like this, though he is the one who drafted TMIII in New Orleans, so probably has a good understanding of what he’s worth.
Before I dissect this trade, I do want to say that I like TMIII and think he’s a good player, but I am far from the camp that thinks he’s worth three first-round picks, not to mention all of the Pistons’ shooting.
This is a trade that looks good to NBA2K fans but actually creates more problems than is solves.
Trey Murphy III doesn’t solve the Pistons’ biggest issue
The Pistons upgraded their shooting in the offseason, and it has worked out so far, as they are top 10 in 3-point percentage and are taking and making more 3’s than they did last season.
Duncan Robinson is a HUGE part of that, so trading him should be a non-starter for any deal that just brings back another shooter. Let’s be real here, Robinson has been better than TMIII this season, so why give him up for a theoretical upgrade?
The Pistons can’t make any trade in which they send out two of their best shooters for one guy, unless that guy is a star, and TMIII is borderline at best. He’s a good shooter, who fits well with Cade Cunningham, but he’s not a creator, so why not just keep the two shooters they have, who make about as much as TMIII combined?
Then you get to the picks.
Three picks for a non-All-Star who is hurt and averaging 15 points per game is ludicrous, especially with the new lottery rules that make these picks even more difficult to predict.
You could argue that TMIII is young enough and would complete the Pistons’ core in some ways, so they wouldn’t really need draft picks, but no matter how good you are, teams must keep a steady stream of developmental talent coming in or are going to be playing with a roster of 7-8 real NBA players on it.
Trading two shooters for one is just trading strength for strength and when you pile on three picks, it just creates more problems than it solves for the Pistons.
